In a twist that would make Karl Marx smile and Adam Smith spin in his grave, President Trump’s recent economic moves have accidentally created the very socialist system his supporters claim to despise. Through a series of interventions that would make any central planner proud, the champion of free enterprise has become America’s most effective socialist leader.
Consider the evidence. When Trump demanded that AMD and NVIDIA pay a 15 percent export tax on chips sold to China, he didn’t just impose a tariff — he created a system where the government dictates which companies can sell to which customers and at what price.
This isn’t the invisible hand of the market — it’s the very visible fist of state control.
Trump’s request for Intel’s CEO to resign takes us even further down the socialist path. Since when does the leader of a capitalist nation hire and fire private company executives? That’s a page straight from the playbook of state-controlled economies, where business leaders serve at the pleasure of political authorities rather than shareholders.
But the real masterpiece of accidental socialism comes from Trump’s approach to consumer prices. By imposing high tariffs on imported goods — costs that American consumers must pay — while simultaneously telling Amazon and Walmart what they can charge, Trump has created a classic command economy scenario. The government raises costs through tariffs, then controls prices to hide the impact. This is exactly how socialist economies operated: artificial price controls that ignore market reality.
Friedrich Hayek, the famous economist and critic of socialism, warned us about this very thing. He wrote, “The curious task of economics is to demonstrate to men how little they really know about what they imagine they can design.” Trump imagines he can design an economy where tariffs protect American workers, export taxes punish China, and price controls protect consumers — all at the same time. Hayek would recognize this as the “fatal conceit” of central planning.
What makes this particularly remarkable is that it’s happening under a Republican administration. For decades, conservatives have (correctly) argued that price controls lead to shortages, that government shouldn’t pick winners and losers in business, and that free trade benefits consumers. Yet here we are, with a Republican president implementing policies that would make European socialists blush.
The results are predictable. When you tell companies they can’t raise prices despite higher costs from tariffs, they’ll find other ways to cope—reducing quality, cutting selection, or simply stopping sales of affected items. When you interfere with corporate leadership, you signal to every CEO that political loyalty matters more than business performance.
This accidental socialism also reveals something important about government power. Once you accept that Washington can impose tariffs “for national security,” it’s a short step to export taxes “for fairness.” Once you believe the president should influence corporate leadership, why not control prices too? Each intervention justifies the next, until the free market exists only in memory.
The American economy’s strength has always come from its freedom — the ability of businesses to serve customers, set prices, and choose leaders without political interference. By abandoning these principles, even with good intentions, Trump has created a system that looks less like Reagan’s America and more like the controlled economies conservatives once opposed.
Perhaps the greatest irony is that Trump’s supporters, many of whom rail against “socialism,” cheer these moves. They don’t recognize price controls when they’re called “fighting inflation,” or state economic planning when it’s labeled “America First.” The socialism they feared from the left has arrived from the right, wrapped in a flag and promising to make America great again.
As Hayek knew, the road to economic control is paved with good intentions. Trump may believe he’s protecting American workers and consumers, but he’s actually building the very system of government control that makes true prosperity impossible. Welcome to America’s socialist paradise — you just didn’t expect it to arrive wearing a red MAGA hat.
Robert May is CEO of Neurometric and a Managing Director at HalfCourt Capital..
Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
For the latest news, weather, sports, and streaming video, head to The Hill.
