New Zealand’s spy service warned Thursday that China is the most active power engaging in foreign interference in the country, sparking a sharp rebuke from Beijing.
New Zealand faces the “most challenging national security environment of recent times”, the country’s intelligence agency said in an annual risk assessment.
Key drivers of the deteriorating threat environment were less stable relationships between states, deepening polarisation and growing grievances.
Though several states seek to manipulate New Zealand’s government and society, China remains the “most active”, the New Zealand Security Intelligence Service said.
China’s embassy in Wellington accused the agency of sowing suspicion and “poisoning the two countries’ relations”.
“The accusations sound very familiar as they rehash smears and slanders fabricated elsewhere, repackaged for the New Zealand audience,” an embassy spokesperson said.
“We have regarded, and are willing to continue to regard New Zealand as a friend and partner. But the healthy and stable development of bilateral relations depends on the joint efforts from both sides.”
New Zealand’s spy agency specifically accused China’s United Front Work Department of engaging in foreign interference to build influence outside of China.
– ‘Deceptive, coercive’ –
Not all of its activity amounted to foreign interference, and some could be beneficial, it said.
“However, its activities are regularly deceptive, coercive and corruptive and come with risks for New Zealand organisations.”
The agency cautioned New Zealand businesses that under China’s national security legislation, individuals and organisations in China must comply with requests from the country’s security services.
The Indo-Pacific region is a focal point for strategic competition between powers, the security service said.
China is a “particularly assertive and powerful actor”, seeking to extend and embed its influence across the region, the report said.
“It has demonstrated both a willingness and capability to undertake intelligence activity that targets New Zealand’s national interests.”
Without naming countries, the intelligence service highlighted the routine use of “transnational repression” by foreign states, often by co-opting people to collect information about someone within their own diaspora living in New Zealand.
Looking at other risks, the agency said the most plausible extremist threat in New Zealand remained that of a lone actor, radicalised in an increasingly polarised, grievance-laden online world, who attacks without forewarning.
Young and vulnerable people were at the highest risk of radicalisation, it said.
– Undetected espionage –
The intelligence organisation said it was “almost certain” that some foreign espionage activity was going undetected.
Foreign countries were targeting critical organisations, infrastructure and technology — mostly through cyber exploitation, it said.
“It is not just intelligence officers conducting this activity,” the agency said.
“Some governments take a ‘whole of state approach’ to intelligence gathering, which includes utilising businesses, universities, think tanks, or cyber actors to act on their behalf.”
Global competition and insecurity drive most of the espionage activity against New Zealand, it said.
The service cited “multiple examples” of states seeking covert access to information on government policy positions, security partnerships, technological innovations and research.
djw/sft/lec/cwl
